In 2009 a 16 year-old Naples teen was tragically killed in a car crash, leaving his friends and family behind to mourn their sudden loss. He wasn’t driving recklessly, nor was the vehicle that struck him and his friend. His 16 year-old friend behind the wheel of the car was was driving under the influence with a blood alcohol level more than twice the legal limit. It was a serious mistake she will live with for the rest of her life.
What should be the punishment for this young 16 year-old who didn’t have the common sense to NOT drink and drive? Unfortunately, too often people get behind the wheel of a car to drive after drinking or taking prescription or non-prescription drugs. It is a decision people make that can have severe long lasting consequences.
In this tragic case, someone’s son and brother - lost his life due to the negligence of a girl who made the wrong decision. Although the 16 year-old driver survived the accident, she may wish she hadn’t. The court ruled she will NEVER be allowed to drive again and sentenced her to 6-9 months in a moderate-risk program for teens who commit non-violent crimes. It is here she will receive rehabilitation and punishment for the crime she committed. The remorse and reminders, of course, will never go away.
Children should be taught NOT to drink underage, not to drive under the influence, and not to get in a car with an impaired driver. This could have been prevented, had these teens made different choices. The young man should have never gotten into the vehicle with his friend who had been drinking, the driver should never have gotten behind the wheel drunk, and neither of the teens should have been drinking in the first place.
Who provided these minors with alcohol in the first place? Perhaps some degree of blame should be given to whomever sold or provided them with alcohol. There can be legal responsibility for those who provide alcohol to minors and then injure another. A store, a parent of a friend who provided the alcohol, or adults who host or allow a party where alcohol was served may be held liable in the event of another’s injury or death resulting from from their providing alcohol to a minor.



